Skip to content
Illustration for What Executives Get Wrong on Earnings Calls
Source: Seeking Alpha

What Executives Get Wrong on Earnings Calls

Eamon Blackthorn
By Eamon Blackthorn Author of the best-selling book Say It Right Every Time
3 min read Business & Leadership

What Happened

Elders Limited, an Australian agricultural services company, held its Q4 2026 earnings call on November 15, 2026. CEO René Dedoncker and Group Finance lead Paul Rossiter addressed investors and analysts. Earnings calls like this one are high-stakes communication events: every word is recorded, scrutinized, and used to judge not just the numbers, but the people delivering them.

The Communication Angle

Here is the lesson every executive needs to hear before stepping onto an earnings call: your numbers tell investors what happened, but your words tell them whether to trust you.

Most executives treat earnings calls as a financial reporting exercise. They prep on the data and wing the communication. That is exactly backwards. Analysts already have the spreadsheets. What they are actually listening for is confidence, clarity, and whether the person in charge sounds like they understand their own business.

The most common failure on these calls is what I call the "data shield." An executive buries every answer in figures, ratios, and qualifications because they think precision sounds credible. It does not. It sounds like deflection. When a CEO rattles off six metrics in response to a simple question about growth strategy, the message investors actually receive is: "I am hiding behind numbers because I do not want to commit to anything." Specificity is not the same as clarity. You can be very specific and still say nothing.

The second failure is passive voice creep. Listen to any underperforming earnings call and you will hear phrases like "challenges were encountered" or "headwinds were experienced." Nobody encountered those challenges. The company did. The leadership did. The moment you strip the subject out of a sentence, you strip accountability with it. Investors notice. They may not be able to name the technique, but they feel the evasion in their gut and they mark you down for it.

What strong earnings call communication looks like is this: short declarative sentences, first-person ownership of both wins and losses, and a forward statement that is specific enough to be held to. Not "we expect to see improvement in key areas." That sentence means nothing. Instead: "We are targeting a 12% margin recovery in our core rural services division by mid-year, and here is what we are doing to get there." That sentence does three things at once. It shows command, it sets a benchmark, and it gives analysts something to track. That is a communicator doing their job.

This is exactly the kind of scenario I break down in Say It Right Every Time. The chapter on accountability language gives you a framework for auditing your own speech patterns before high-pressure situations, so you stop communicating like someone who is covering themselves and start communicating like someone who is in charge. The difference is not just stylistic. It determines whether people follow you or simply tolerate you.

Say It Right Every Time by Eamon Blackthorn

Never Be Lost
for Words Again

By Eamon Blackthorn

Get word‑for‑word scripts for the conversations that shape your life, from job interviews and negotiations to difficult talks with family and partners, so you always know exactly what to say and how to say it.

Go to Book PageFrom $9.97 USD
PaperbackHardcoverKindleAudiobook
Say It Right Every Time by Eamon Blackthorn

Never Be Lost
for Words Again

By Eamon Blackthorn

Get word‑for‑word scripts for the conversations that shape your life, from job interviews and negotiations to difficult talks with family and partners, so you always know exactly what to say and how to say it.

Go to Book PageFrom $9.97 USD
PaperbackHardcoverKindleAudiobook

Key Takeaway

Before your next high-stakes presentation or investor update, strip out every passive construction from your prepared remarks. Go sentence by sentence. If the subject of the sentence is not your company, your team, or yourself, rewrite it. Own the action. Own the result. This one edit will make your communication sound more confident and more credible than any amount of polish or rehearsal.

More in Business & Leadership

Illustration for What Hilton's CEO Gets Right About Workplace Culture
Business & Leadership

What Hilton's CEO Gets Right About Workplace Culture

Hilton has held onto its title as the world's best workplace for two consecutive years. CEO Chris Nassetta recently explained the philosophy behind it: invest in your people, give everyone a shared goal, and make sure your company's values aren't just words on a wall. They have to live at every level of the organization, from the C-suite down to the front desk.

Illustration for What Hilton's CEO Got Right About Communicating Success
Business & Leadership

What Hilton's CEO Got Right About Communicating Success

Hilton has earned recognition as the world's best workplace, and CEO Chris Nassetta is pointing directly at one cause: years of deliberate, consistent investment in the people who work there. Nassetta framed this not as a campaign or a cultural initiative, but as a long game. The company did not arrive here quickly, and Nassetta is not pretending otherwise.

Illustration for What CEOs Get Wrong Talking to Their Board
Business & Leadership

What CEOs Get Wrong Talking to Their Board

McKinsey recently published guidance on how boards and CEOs can work together more effectively. The piece identifies three core areas where the relationship between a company's top executive and its governing board tends to break down. The core argument is that stronger collaboration between these two groups produces better outcomes for the organization. This is not a new idea, but the execution of it remains a persistent problem in boardrooms worldwide.

Illustration for Social Media Skills Now Drive C-Suite Promotions
Business & Leadership

Social Media Skills Now Drive C-Suite Promotions

The path to executive leadership is shifting. Companies are increasingly valuing social media fluency as a core leadership competency, not a marketing afterthought. Executives who can build a public voice, engage audiences directly, and shape narratives online are moving up faster than those who rely solely on traditional credentials and closed-door relationship building.

Illustration for What Executives Get Wrong on Earnings Calls

Enjoyed this article?

What Executives Get Wrong on Earnings Calls

Elders Limited, an Australian agricultural services company, held its Q4 2026 earnings call on November 15, 2026. CEO René Dedoncker and Group Finance lead Paul Rossiter addressed investors and analysts. Earnings calls like this one are high-stakes communication events: every word is recorded, scrutinized, and used to judge not just the numbers, but the people delivering them.

Share it with someone who needs to hear this.

Share